Oscar and Florida Blue both sell individual health plans in Florida that cover mental health care, including therapy and, on many plans, intensive outpatient programs (IOP). The differences that matter most are who runs each company’s behavioral health network, which plan and network type you pick, and whether your therapist or program is in that exact network. Your 2027 premium and out-of-pocket maximum depend on the specific plan, not the brand.
Open enrollment for 2027 Marketplace plans runs from November 1, 2026 to January 15, 2027. This guide compares the two carriers on the points that change how you get mental health care in Florida.
This article is informational, not clinical or financial advice. Verify benefits directly with your plan and a licensed clinician before choosing coverage or starting treatment.
Oscar vs Florida Blue: the short answer

Here is the side by side view based on each company’s own public pages. Plan details change every year, so confirm the 2027 version of any plan before you enroll.
| Question | Oscar | Florida Blue |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | A national insurer that sells individual and family plans | Florida’s Blue Cross Blue Shield company |
| Who manages behavioral health | Handled within your Oscar plan; check your card for the mental health number | Lucet, which Florida Blue names as its behavioral health care administrator |
| Therapy coverage | Oscar says its plans include in-network therapists and psychiatrists, with no referral required | Covered on its plans; Lucet helps members find in-network therapists |
| Virtual therapy | Oscar advertises $0 virtual therapy options | Lucet can help schedule in-person or virtual visits |
| Prior authorization for IOP | Usually required; check your plan | Usually required; check your plan |
| 2027 plans in your county | Check HealthCare.gov | Check HealthCare.gov |
Are both carriers selling Florida plans for 2027?
Oscar’s site already advertises its 2027 open enrollment. Which plans are offered in your county is something to confirm on HealthCare.gov once 2027 plans are listed.
HealthCare.gov lists the open enrollment dates. Enroll by December 15 for coverage that starts January 1, or by January 15 for coverage that starts February 1. After that, you generally need a qualifying life event to change plans.
Florida’s insurance market is overseen by the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation. If a plan detail is unclear, the plan documents and the regulator’s records are better sources than any ad.
Who handles behavioral health at each company?
Many insurers send mental health benefits to a specialty team that keeps the therapist network and reviews higher levels of care. Knowing who that team is saves you time on the phone.
- Florida Blue: Its behavioral health page names Lucet as its behavioral health care administrator. Lucet can help members find a licensed therapist and may help schedule in-person or virtual visits.
- Oscar: Its mental health resources page says Oscar plans include in-network access to therapists, psychiatrists and mental health services, with no referral required. Members find providers through the Oscar app or account.
For either carrier, the phone number on the back of your card is the most reliable starting point. Ask specifically for behavioral health or mental health benefits, not general customer service.
How do plan and network types differ?
Both companies sell more than one kind of plan, and the plan type shapes your options. HealthCare.gov describes the main plan and network types. HMOs and EPOs generally cover in-network care only, so check the plan type before you assume you can see anyone.
- HMO: Usually covers only providers who contract with the plan, except emergencies, and may require referrals.
- EPO: Covers only network providers, except emergencies, and often without referrals.
- PPO: Pays something toward out-of-network care, at a higher cost, without a referral.
- POS: You pay less in network and usually need a referral to see a specialist.
Florida Blue plans can use different networks depending on the plan you choose. The network name on a plan matters as much as the Florida Blue brand, because a provider in one Florida Blue network may not be in another. The same check applies to every Oscar plan you consider.
What both must cover: the parity floor
Every Marketplace plan covers mental health as an essential health benefit. HealthCare.gov explains that all Marketplace plans must cover behavioral health treatment, such as psychotherapy and counseling. Parity rules also mean mental health limits generally cannot be stricter than comparable medical limits.
Those parity protections cover costs like copays, visit limits and care management rules such as prior authorization. The federal Mental Health Parity and Addiction Equity Act is the law behind them. It does not mean every program is in every network.
How does IOP get approved with Oscar or Florida Blue?
An intensive outpatient program typically means nine or more hours of structured care each week while you live at home. On most commercial plans, from either carrier, IOP needs prior authorization before it starts.
HealthCare.gov defines prior authorization as the plan deciding a service is medically necessary before you get it. In practice, the program usually submits the request for you.
- A clinician assesses you and documents why a higher level of care fits.
- The program sends the request to the behavioral health team for your plan.
- The plan approves a set number of days or sessions.
- The program requests more time with progress notes, if you still need it.
Virtual IOP can be a practical choice across a large state like Florida. A study in the Journal of Psychiatric Research found telehealth and in-person intensive treatment for adults produced comparable results. Learn more on our intensive outpatient program page.
How to check that a provider is in network
Directories are a starting point, not proof. A provider can be listed under one plan’s network but not under the network your plan actually uses.
Open Enrollment 2027 in Indiana: Picking a Plan for Mental HealthInsurance
- Search the exact plan, not just the carrier name, in the Oscar app or Florida Blue’s Find a Doctor tool.
- Call the provider and give them your plan name and network, not just “Florida Blue” or “Oscar”.
- Call the behavioral health number on your card and ask whether IOP by telehealth is covered.
- Write down the date, name and reference number for every call.

If a claim or approval is denied, you can appeal. HealthCare.gov explains how to appeal a health plan decision. Florida’s Division of Consumer Services also helps residents with insurance questions.
Which one should you pick for mental health in 2027?
There is no single right answer, because the best plan depends on your providers and your budget. Use these questions to narrow it down.
- Is your current therapist or psychiatrist in the network of the exact plan you are looking at?
- What is the copay or coinsurance for outpatient therapy and for intensive outpatient care?
- What is the out-of-pocket maximum, the most you would pay for covered in-network care in a year?
- Does the plan cover telehealth the same way as in-person visits?
- What plan type is it, and does that fit how you want to get care?
Our guide to reading mental health insurance benefits explains each of these terms in plain language.
Common questions about Oscar vs Florida Blue
Is Oscar or Florida Blue better for mental health?
Neither is better for everyone. The right choice depends on whether your providers are in the plan’s network and what the plan charges for therapy and IOP.
Does Florida Blue use a separate company for mental health?
Florida Blue names Lucet as its behavioral health care administrator. Lucet helps members find therapists and may help schedule visits.
Does Oscar require a referral for therapy?
Oscar’s mental health page says no referral is required for therapy. Check your own plan documents to confirm.
Do Oscar and Florida Blue cover IOP in Florida?
Many plans from both carriers cover intensive outpatient care when it is medically necessary, usually with prior authorization. Check your plan’s summary for exact costs.
Will Oscar and Florida Blue offer plans in my county for 2027?
Check HealthCare.gov during open enrollment, which runs November 1, 2026 to January 15, 2027. Plan availability varies by county.
Does Thrive work with Oscar or Florida Blue?
Thrive Mental Health works with most major commercial plans, including Oscar and Blue Cross Blue Shield plans, and networks vary by plan and state. Check your plan or ask us to verify for free.
Next steps
If you live in Florida and weekly therapy is not enough, a benefits check can show what intensive outpatient care would cost on your plan. Thrive Mental Health is a Joint Commission accredited provider of virtual IOP for adults in Florida, Indiana, Arizona, California, North Carolina, South Carolina and Texas. Read more on our Oscar and Blue Cross Blue Shield coverage pages; networks vary by plan, so check your plan or ask us to verify.
Verify your coverage with Thrive: free, confidential benefits check. Most members receive a summary within 24 hours, and you can start as soon as you are ready. Prefer to talk first? Call (561) 203-6085 or contact us.
This article is for informational purposes only and is not a substitute for individualized clinical advice or insurance verification.



